TEN PIZZA PLACES TO TRY
ON HILTON HEAD
If you're on the hunt for the best pizza pie on Hilton Head Island,
here are 10 places to try before picking your fav!
*Specials, events, business openings and other details may change. We recommend calling ahead to confirm.
​
DOUGH BOYS PIZZA
Intimate joint featuring classic & unique pizzas, sandwiches & calzones in a low-key setup.
​
We recommend: The plain cheese pie. Soooo good!
LOCAL PIE
Local Pie is the 1st and only true Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizza on Hilton Head Island.
​
We recommend: The Monkey - a garlic olive oil “white pie”, house mozzarella, mozzarella, sharp provolone, shaved Parmesan, house ricotta, and Bluffton herbs.
FAT BABY'S
PIZZA & SUBS
​
Counter-service joint making thin-crust pies & sandwiches in a relaxed setting with a jukebox & TVs.
We recommend: "The Fat Baby" with pepperoni, sausage, meatball, onion, green pepper, black olive, mushroom and extra cheese.
FROSTY FROG
CAFE & PIZZA
Laid-back beach-themed daiquiri bar with TVs & patio seating also serves salads, sandwiches & pizza.
We recommend: Jude's Margherita, freshly made pizza sauce topped with fresh mozzarella, pesto and fresh basil.
SUPER BAKED
Starting with a decades old family dumpling recipe, Super Baked has developed amazing made-from-scratch dough. A fun mom and pop environment with quality pizza, delicious wings and reasonable prices lets our customers dine-in, carryout or get delivered a Super Baked experience.
​
We recommend: The Traditional Pepperoni (and an order of the "Slightly Baked" Chocolate Chip Cookies.)
TJ'S TAKE & BAKE
PIZZA COMPANY
Hand made to order take and bake pies and fresh signature salads are what you'll find plenty of at TJ's.
​
We recommend: The Build Your Own Take and Bake.
NEW YORK CITY PIZZA
Lively, casual pizzeria, with a bar, serving NY-style pizza & other Italian basics.
​
We recommend: The Deep Dish Pan Pizza.
MANGIAMO'S
Laid-back bar & eatery serving pizza, pasta & wings doubles as a local hangout for Ohio State games.
​
We recommend: The Spicy Chicken Pizza with homemade ranch dressing, mozzarella cheese, chicken tossed in homemade buffalo sauce and bacon.
BELLA ITALIA PIZZA
Straightforward pizza parlor whipping up specialty & gluten-free pies, plus subs & Italian entrees.
​
We recommend: The Margherita Thin with olive oil blended with garlic & herbs, served with tomatoes & fresh basil.
GUISEPPI'S PIZZA & PASTA
Family-friendly spot for pizza, "weggies" (wrap-type sandwiches in pizza dough) & Italian basics.
We recommend: Giuseppi’s Ultimate White with garlic olive oil and artichokes, fresh spinach and tomato, parmesan, ricotta, provolone and mozzarella cheeses.
​
Or for a tasty gluten free treat, try the Giuseppe's Cauliflower Pizza.